The diagnosis and management of Guy E Thwaites

INTRODUCTION The postmortem observations of Green, published in the Lancet in 1836, were the fi rst to describe the distinct pathological features of tuberculous meningitis and set it apart from the other recognised causes of ‘acute hydrocephalus’ (Green 1836). The challenge for the physician then lay in distinguishing the disease before death, and delivering the grave prognosis. Thomas Mann captures the full horror of this process in Dr Faustus as the helpless Dr Kurbis presides over the agonizing death of a small child from tuberculous meningitis: The whole thing lasted scarcely two weeks, including the earliest signs that all was not quite well with the child; from the beginnings no one – I believe no one at all – even dreamed of the horror to come ... Kurbis tested the child’s eyes, the pupils of which were tiny and showed a tendency to squint. The pulse raced. Muscular contractions developed, and an incipient rigidity of the neck. It was cerebrospinal meningitis, infl ammation of the meninges. The good man pronounced the name with a deprecating movement of the head shoulderwards, probably in the hope that they might not know the almost complete powerlessness of medical science in the face of this onslaught. Tuberculous meningitis was invariably fatal before the advent of anti-tuberculosis chemotherapy. Therefore, the need to diagnose the disorder became a priority after streptomycin was found to reduce mortality of tuberculous meningitis by one third in 1948 (MRC 1948). Progress was rapid over the next 5 years: adding para-aminosalicylic acid to streptomycin reduced mortality to 30%, and the addition of isoniazid to both of these compounds lowered the mortality still more to Robert Koch: photograph taken in the 1880s, around the time of his discovery of the tubercle bacillus (or ‘bacille Koch’, as it is still called in Vietnam).